Is Magothy Payments a Legit Processor? Real Feedback & Truths

We take our role in providing guidance and education regarding the card payment industry very seriously. At our own expense, we have vigorously defended our right to continue expose unethical and predatory practices in the industry, successfully defeating every attempt to silence us. However, fending off frivolous lawsuits is costly. To sustain these efforts, one of the ways we generate revenue is through affiliate partnerships with ethical providers. This means that some of our outgoing links connect business owners to trustworthy, low-cost payment processors, which is what most of our readers seek. We see this revenue channel as a win-win-win for everyone involved. Business owners find good processors, processors get good clients, and we are able to continue to provide a valuable service to the small business community. We also recommend and link to many services that do not compensate us. Our priority is to guide you to the best solutions for your needs, regardless of potential revenue. If you have questions, please feel free to contact us.

All mentions of rate and fee costs are estimations based on publicly available information and client feedback. Actual costs may vary based on a variety of factors unique to your business.

Magothy Payments

Rating
A
5/5
full starfull starfull starfull starfull star

Pros and Cons of Magothy Payments

Pros

Transparent pricing model
Month-to-month contracts
No early termination
No hidden fees
Flexible payment solutions

Cons

Setup fees apply
Monthly minimum fee
PCI compliance fees
Equipment leasing options
Limited high-risk support

Overview

In this review of Magothy Payments, we take a closer look at the company’s credit card processing services. Their offerings include point-of-sale systems, mobile payments, and e-commerce solutions designed for a range of businesses. We’ll highlight which businesses may benefit most from these services. We’ll also review customer feedback to show common trends and concerns. In addition, we’ll cover pricing, contract terms, and included services. By the end, you’ll know whether Magothy Payments is the right fit for your business.

About Magothy Payments

Screen Capture of Magothy Payments Homepage
Magothy Payments Homepage

Founded in 2014, Magothy Payments is a merchant account provider that is capable of serving most standard-risk business types. The company is one of the most positively reviewed payment processors on CPO. Magothy Payments focuses on companies that require ‘card not present’ payment processing as well as businesses that utilize lots of reoccurring billing for services or membership. Magothy’s largest client base is contractors in home and commercial, but it also works with e-commerce companies, B2B, and other companies with recurring and card-on-file billing. Magothy Payments is also an Authorize.Net reseller.

Commitment to Industry Reforms

Magothy Payments has a dedicated section on its website about Maryland House Bill 777. This section outlines the company’s support for the legislation aimed at reforming practices related to early termination fees and liquidated damages clauses in merchant agreements. Signed into law in 2019 and effective from October 1, 2019, the law requires that contract terms, cancellation fees, liquidated damages, and renewal dates be clearly stated in 12-point bold font. It also caps early termination fees at $500 for contracts signed or renewed after the effective date. Magothy Payments’ advocacy for this law highlights its commitment to ethical standards, appealing to prospective merchants.

Products & Merchant Services

Payment Processing

Magothy Payments has shifted its focus toward serving firearm businesses and gun merchants. With Elavon known for being supportive of Second Amendment businesses, Magothy Payments offers lower swipe rates to these merchants, who are often classified as high-risk. Merchants with a federal firearms license are not subject to high-risk premiums.

Payment Gateway and Virtual Terminals

Beyond physical payment processing, Magothy Payments provides online payment solutions. These solutions enable businesses to accept credit and debit card payments over the internet, supporting both e-commerce and brick-and-mortar businesses.

Customer Reviews & Sentiment

Highly Positive Reputation

Currently, there are no negative Magothy Payments reviews available, suggesting a clean record with no reported scams or ripoffs. Despite the abundance of online reviews, all feedback appears to be overwhelmingly positive. While many of these reviews are unverified, there is no apparent reason to doubt their authenticity. Clients commonly commend the company for its transparency and proactive customer service. If you have had an experience with Magothy Payments, we encourage you to share your review in the comments section below.

Legal History and Regulatory Compliance

No significant class-action lawsuits or FTC complaints have been filed against Magothy Payments. Dissatisfied clients seeking recourse can explore reporting their concerns to relevant supervisory organizations for resolution.

Customer Support Excellence

Magothy Payments provides live phone support to all its clients, reflecting its commitment to exceptional customer service. The consistently positive reputation of its customer support department positions the company competitively alongside the top-rated payment processors for outstanding customer service.

Industry Scores & User Ratings

Online Ratings Summary
PaymentPop5
BBB RatingN/A
Google Maps4.9
Average Rating4.95

PaymentPop Rating for Magothy Payments

Negative Feedback

There are no negative reviews published about Magothy Payments on the PaymentPop website.

Positive Feedback

Magothy has been great to deal with. If we have any issues at all they are right on top of it. I highly recommend them!

Magothy Payments BBB Rating

Magothy Payments currently has an “A+” rating with the Better Business Bureau and has been BBB-accredited since December 2016. The company has received 0 complaints in the last 34 months it has been active.

What Merchants Say

Magothy currently has no reviews on its profile, though it previously received 2 positive informal reviews. The most recent review was left by a client who describes the company’s effect on them being able to save on the cost of services:

Magothy Payments has saved me Thousands of Dollars a year. Super Helpful when it comes to customer service. If your not using Magothy Payments chances are you are probably being overcharged and cant even get them on the phone. Magothy has the best rates available (Trust me i looked around) and extremely professional. You wont find another company this good.

This review describes traits that embody the best available merchant account providers.

An “A” Performance

Given the company’s clean complaint record, we agree with the BBB’s rating at this time.

Google Maps Rating for Magothy Payments

Magothy Payments has a 4.9 out of 5 star rating based on 76 user reviews on Google Maps.

Positive Feedback

The team at Magothy Payments are professional and are experts in their field. They provide great customer support and go above and beyond for their clients. Highly recommended!

Negative Feedback

There are no negative reviews published about Magothy Payments on Google Maps.

Processing Rates & Fees

Month-to-Month Contract

The Magothy Payments merchant agreement offers a flexible month-to-month contract via Elavon without an early termination fee. It incorporates a monthly minimum fee of $10 and a PCI non-compliance fee, which is often covered by Magothy, effectively reducing it to zero for the majority of clients. The agreement specifies a monthly statement/support fee of $10 and a transaction fee of $0.10 (plus interchange at 0.75% and $0.10 for American Express cards). Magothy Payments limits chargeback fees to $99 annually, providing immediate notifications to merchants about any chargebacks.

Virtual Terminal and Payment Gateway Pricing

Magothy Payments promotes its virtual terminal and payment gateway solutions, powered by NMI, without specific pricing details disclosed by NMI. Magothy’s contract, however, lists a gateway fee of $15 per month plus $0.10 per transaction. This e-commerce service may involve additional costs such as technical support fees, batch fees, and extra transaction rates.

Other Magothy Fees

Magothy Payments charges a one-time setup fee of $249, reduced to $99 for new owner-operated businesses. This fee encompasses payment gateway customization, reporting tools setup, PCI compliance assistance, and staff training. Should clients be dissatisfied after one billing cycle, Magothy offers a full refund of this setup fee—a guarantee that, according to a company representative, has never been claimed. Chargeback fees are capped at $99 per year, with proactive notifications for merchants.

Magothy PCI Compliance Fee

Magothy’s PCI compliance fee varies with each merchant’s specific payment solution and the level of liability coverage, charged monthly at either $8 (for $100,000 in coverage) or $12 (for $250,000 in coverage) for physical terminals, and $7 (for $20,000 in coverage) for e-commerce or mail/telephone order (MOTO) solutions. Magothy encourages buying over leasing terminals, though leasing options are available upon request.

Alternate Pricing Options

Magothy provides tailored pricing for businesses with high transaction volumes and ensures their interchange-plus markup will not increase. Following a month of processing, Magothy conducts an analysis to verify if they have successfully reduced the client’s effective rate, avoiding tiered pricing models.

Worth The Cost

While some fees such as setup and statement fees are generally discouraged, Magothy Payments justifies its fee structure through significant savings and superior support for its clients. There are no complaints found regarding excessive charges or unfair contract terms. Feedback from Magothy Payments reviews frequently highlights the company’s competitive pricing and the value provided. This positive feedback contributes to Magothy Payments receiving an “A” rating in this category.

Business owners in search of competitive merchant services are recommended to review our selection of the best merchant accounts.

Employee Reviews & Sales Practices

Inside/Outside Sales Team

Magothy Payments appears to primarily rely on referrals and networking to advertise its services. It employs W-2 and 1099 sales agents but requires its 1099 sales agents to comply with the company’s pricing guidelines. We are currently unable to locate any Magothy Payments reviews that accuse the company of nondisclosure or misrepresentation. In fact, there are a large number of positive testimonials about the company’s honesty and transparency.

This compares favorably to our list of best credit card processors.

No Deceptive Quotes

Magothy Payments prominently advertises that it offers interchange-plus pricing and does not enforce long-term contracts or early termination fees. The company’s owner has reinforced those claims by leading the charge to pass legislation in the state of Maryland that requires the client’s initials next to all major contract terms and caps all merchant cancellation fees at a total of $500. The full text of the bill, which takes effect in October 2019, can be seen here. In combination with the lack of complaints and a large number of positive merchant reviews, this is a strong indication that Magothy Payments is committed to fair dealing and honest sales practices.

If you suspect, however, that the company is overcharging you, then you can double-check your monthly bill with a third-party statement audit.

Magothy Payments Competitors

Compare Magothy Payments to competitors that earned top marks.

Bottom Line

Magothy Payments ranks as an exemplary credit card processing provider according to our rating criteria. The company emphasizes competitive contract terms while prioritizing transparency and customer service. This approach has helped it earn a strong reputation in the industry. However, our rating remains flexible, as we continue to monitor client feedback to ensure it remains accurate and reflective of real-world experiences.

Merchants are still advised to carefully review the terms of any contract they are presented with to avoid unexpected fees or obligations. For now, Magothy Payments stands out as an option on par with the highest-rated processors listed on CPO, making it a compelling choice for businesses seeking reliable and customer-focused payment processing.

Read Actual User Reviews

All user reviews have been moved to our partner, PaymentPop.com

Contact Magothy Payments

Contact & Customer Support
Owner and CEOJaron Rice
Headquarters517 Benfield Rd, Suite 101A, Severna Park, Maryland 21146
Toll-Free Support(855) 624-6849
Websitemagothy.biz