Smart Choice Payments Review

Smart Choice Payments Logo
full star full star empty star empty star empty star

How did they treat you? ▼

8/4/2019 Update: As of this update, it has become apparent that Smart Choice Payments has been absorbed into the Velocity, LLC brand. The company’s website redirects visitors to Velocity’s. Merchant’s should defer to our review of Velocity, LLC as such. The review below reflects all data pertaining to North American Processing Payments as of May 28, 2019. While this review will remain intact for reference purposes, it will no longer be updated.

A Company of Many Names

Headquartered in Beaverton, Oregon, Smart Choice Payments is a merchant account provider that offers credit card processing for most domestic business types. The company is a DBA of Wholesale Merchant Processing and of First Choice Payments, and it also appears to be a DBA of North American Processing Solutions.

Discontinued and Newly Launched Brands

According to a complaint on our Payment Systems Corporation review, Smart Choice Payments, First Choice Payments, and North American Processing Solutions are subsidiaries of Payment Systems Corporation, which rates as one of the worst merchant account providers we have ever reviewed. Payment Systems Corporation has been out of business for years, and it appears that First Choice Payments and Wholesale Merchant Processing have also gone out of business in the past two years.

Based in Oregon

Todd McCartney is listed as the president of Wholesale Merchant Processing, Smart Choice Payments, and American Payment Systems. All three companies are headquartered at 10250 SW Greenburg Rd. Ste. 200, Portland, Oregon 97223. Smart Choice Payments is a registered ISO/MSP of Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., Walnut Creek, California.

Smart Choice Payments Review Table of Contents

  • Costs & Contract: Smart Choice Payments offers a three-year contract with an early termination fee of $495.
  • Complaints & Service: Smart Choice Payments has received more than 20 public complaints.
  • BBB Rating: Smart Choice Payments has an “A+” rating with the Better Business Bureau and has received 23 complaints and 8 reviews in the last three years.
  • Sales & Marketing: Smart Choice Payments appears to hire independently contracted agents and has received a moderate number of complaints about its sales team.
  • Rates & Fees: How Merchants Got The Best Rates With Smart Choice Payments

Smart Choice Payments Customer Reviews

Here's What Their Clients Say

Customer Reviews Summary
Total Online Complaints 50+
Live Customer Support Yes
Most Common Complaint Hidden Fees

Moderate-to-High Complaint Total

We are currently able to locate more than 50 negative Smart Choice Payments reviews, some of which accuse the company of being a scam. This total does not include the more than 50 complaints we have found regarding Wholesale Merchant Processing or the additional complaints filed against First Choice Payments and North American Processing Solutions.

Smart Choice Payments Complaint Contents

Common themes among complainants include nondisclosure of contract terms, poor customer service, expensive equipment leases, and an unprofessional work environment. Many complaints (and responses from company representatives) mention Smart Choice and Wholesale Merchant Processing as though they are the same company, so we will not differentiate between the two entities in this section.

Smart Choice Payments Lawsuits

We have not found any outstanding class-action lawsuits or FTC complaints filed against Smart Choice Payments. Dissatisfied merchants who wish to pursue a non-litigious course of action against the company should consider reporting it to the relevant supervisory organizations.

Ripoff Report “Corporate Advocacy”

As noted elsewhere in this review, Smart Choice Payments has paid Ripoff Report in order to participate in that website’s “Corporate Advocacy Program.” This program makes it difficult to find the title and content of targeted complaints on Ripoff Report. Merchants are advised to scroll completely down the page to read the full details of each complaint.

Smart Choice Payments Customer Support Options

Smart Choice has been assigned the same rating in this section as Wholesale Merchant Processing because there is no indication that the companies are different from each other. The company lists phone and email contact information on its website, but its complaint record precludes it from being considered a top merchant account provider for customer service.

Smart Choice Payments Online Ratings

Here's How They Rate Online

Online Ratings Summary
Product & Service Complaints 14
Billing & Collection Complaints 6
Advertising & Sales Complaints 3
Guarantee & Warranty Complaints 0
Delivery Complaints 0

Note: We have adjusted this company’s BBB rating according to our own standards. To better understand why we adjust BBB ratings, please see our Rating Criteria.

Over 25 Complaints

Smart Choice Payments currently has an “A+” rating with the Better Business Bureau and is not BBB-accredited. The company currently has 23 complaints on its BBB profile, with 15 related to product or service issues, nine having to do with billing or collection, and three due to advertising or sales issues. 8 complaints were successfully resolved, while the remaining 15 complaints either were resolved to the dissatisfaction of the merchant or did not receive a final response from the merchant.

What Merchants Say

Smart Choice has also received 8 informal reviews to its BBB profile, two of which were positive in tone and seven of which were negative. The most recent review describes persistent telemarketing tactics:

They do auto dialer cold calls with no way to stop except for blocking the number. They used **SSN**

This merchant might benefit from taking the steps to shut down sales calls.

A “D” Performance Overall

Despite the fact that Smart Choice’s BBB profile is technically separate from Wholesale Merchant Processing’s BBB profile, we do not differentiate between the two companies like the BBB. We will therefore apply Wholesale Merchant Processing’s 28 complaints to Smart Choice Payments’s profile for now, and adjust its rating to a “D” to reflect how our own rating system would score it.

Smart Choice Payments Fees, Rates & Costs

A Closer Look at The Contract

Cost & Fees Summary
Swiped Rate 1.00% - 4.99%
Keyed-in Rate 1.00% - 4.99%
Monthly Statement Fee $10
Monthly Minimum Fee $25
Early Termination Fee Up to $900
PCI Compliance Fee $4.95/mo
Equipment Lease Cost $3,900
Equipment Lease Terms 48-month (locked)

Three-Year Contract

The standard Smart Choice Payments contract (available below) is a three-year agreement with an early termination fee of $495, a monthly PCI compliance fee of $4.95, a monthly minimum fee of $25, a monthly statement fee of $10, and an accompanying non-cancellable, four-year equipment lease through Northern Leasing Systems. In addition, we have found one report of an additional early termination fee of $900 that is charged upon cancellation. This sounds a lot like a similar $893.98 fee charged by Wholesale Merchant Processing, but we are unable to determine why the company charges it under either name.

Beware Long-Term Leases

As with Wholesale Merchant Processing, the company’s merchant account contract terms are more expensive than industry averages and would warrant a rating at least as low as “C” on their own. However, two other factors lower the company’s score in this section to an “F.” First, the company’s agents appear to commonly package their processing agreements with long-term equipment leases through Northern Leasing Systems. Northern Leasing Systems is notorious for selling non-cancellable four-year leases that charge thousands of dollars for equipment that can be purchased for under $500. Second, the regular complaints about nondisclosure of contract terms indicate that many merchants are signing up with the understanding that they will not face many of these fees. This makes the contract’s length and fee structure even more damaging for unsuspecting merchants.

Higher-Than-Average Costs

Smart Choice Payments appears to offer substandard contract terms overall, and we do not consider its pricing to be even remotely competitive with the cheapest merchant accounts. See the Smart Choice Payments Merchant Application and the Smart Choice Payments Program Guide.

Smart Choice Payments Employee Reviews & Sales Tacitcs

Should You Work For Them?

Jobs & Marketing Summary
Employs Independent Resellers Yes
Advertises Deceptive Rates No
Discloses All Important Terms No

Sales Complaints

Like Wholesale Merchant Processing, Smart Choice Payments appears to sell its products and services through a combination of telemarketing and independently contracted sales agents. We have found a number of Smart Choice Payments complaints that cite nondisclosure of contract terms, misrepresentation of rates, and difficulty contacting sales agents after the contract was signed. A number of complaints from former and current employees also describe a “hiring mill” type of environment.

A Familiar Pattern

These complaints generally mirror those filed against Wholesale Merchant Processing, and many Smart Choice complaints also mention WMP as though they are the same company. In our opinion, this means that the dozens of complaints available online about Wholesale Merchant Processing are at least partially applicable to Smart Choice Payments.

Ripoff Report Complaints

Smart Choice Payments has previously paid Ripoff Report in order to participate in that website’s “Corporate Advocacy Program,” which enables Smart Choice to paste its own promotional copy above certain merchant complaints. It is our belief that this practice reflects poorly on any company, as it only makes it harder for merchants to see what other business owners have to say about the company. In addition, Smart Choice appears to be one of a number of DBAs and subsidiary entities that Wholesale Merchant Processing has established across the country. This strategy is commonly used by some providers to spread complaints across multiple brands or to escape the negative reputation of an existing brand.

Some Red Flags

Taking into account the complaints filed against both Wholesale Merchant Processing and Smart Choice, we have assigned Smart Choice a “D” in this section. If you suspect that Smart Choice Payments is charging you undisclosed fees, we recommend seeking a third-party statement audit to find and eliminate hidden costs.

Our Smart Choice Payments Review Summary

Our Final Thoughts

Not a Competitive Option for Most Merchants

Smart Choice Payments rates as a substandard merchant services provider according to our rating criteria. The company does not appear to be substantively different from Wholesale Merchant Processing, which scores very poorly by our standards. Merchants who have been contacted by Smart Choice Payments or Wholesale Merchant Processing are advised to request and review all documentation before signing up. They may also want to consider opting for a top-rated merchant account instead.

If you found this article helpful, please share it!

Which is Most Important for You?

If you had to pick one, which quality would you say will be the most important with your next credit card processor? Tap or click your selection to register your vote:

  1. Low Transaction Fees
  2. No Monthly Fees
  3. No Contract
  4. Reliable Customer Support
  5. Quick Signup

Testimonials & Complaints

How Did Smart Choice Payments Treat You?

20 User Reviews

  • Kim Minert

    This merchant is difficult to reach, difficult to cancel, sent a lying sales representative to me 3 years ago and withheld pertinent information about the account. I am trapped in a leasing agreement with Northern Leasing Equipment and even though my contract with them is up I have to jump through endless hoops to keep them from auto-renewing my contract.

    I would NEVER recommend doing business with Smart Choice Payments or Velocity or any one of the other names this company uses to provide very bad service.

    This post will help: Cancelling Your Merchant Account Without Paying a Fee

    – Phillip

  • Rich Ryland

    Worst company to use for a Merchant Account! I continually had issues with the card machine throughout a period of more than 2 years and eventually when I asked the company to fix an additional issue, the only solution they could come up with was to get another merchant number. When I did get another Merchant number the machine would still not work and because I had to run credit cards I went back to my previous company. I had about 7 months to go with the original agreement I signed, so if I did not charge anything for those months I would owe $319.92. The representative on the phone told me I would be responsible for $893.98 to cancel early. They could have offered me to stay with them until the original agreement matured and I would have only paid $319.92. This company in my opinion does not care about the service they provide but only how they can get the most money out of a situation. STEER CLEAR OF THIS COMPANY!!!!

  • Michelle Martin

    liars and thieves. they don’t put their name anywhere on the sales documentation so you can’t look them up. their contact says that if they provide you with no service, no card reader, no customer support, no technical support, then you still have to pay them. it’s a farce of a contract, but they’ll still send their full-time lawyers after you and waste your time. i spent 3 months on the phone getting this up and working and immediately tried to cancel, but they would not let me. evil evil evil. the sales org in texas was North American Payment Processing ( do not do business with them at all costs. they know how bad these companies are, and they still sell you off to them. so sad and icky and evil and gross human beings.

  • Braden Escobar

    These bastards along with are a scam. They charged me $ 1690 for keycard advertising my company never received. Promised in 90 days and we are almost double that. After many emails and phone calls I was refunded $495 but given the run around for the rest. They were greedy and called several times to get me the “upgrade” for more money.

  • Fred Kamp

    I want to warn anyone considering Smart Choice as their processing co. You can not believe any thing they tell you. Our brief relationship with them was a nightmare and makes me want to run off processors seeking our business.

    • Gleeann kamp

      Absolutely the biggest credit card payment scam ever!!! Our rep Beau told us he would not switch us over until we were 100% satisfied and offered a 2 week trial. It took almost a month for them to supposedly get their machines to do what we needed and by then we had new machines from the company we were already with!!!
      Well he transferred us to his company with out our authorization and his company has since been taking money from our account and we never ever plugged in their machines!! They are total swindlers and we will now see them in court!!!

  • Mike

    Stay away from this company. They actually took over $3,900 from my company bank account after cancelling my credit card service for lack of use. I was shocked as I didn’t receive any advanced notice. I finally got my money returned after 6 months and a lot of headaches. Also you will have to sign a lease for the terminal with Northern Leasing. You really get stuck with using them and there are no ways to early termination of lease. They will charge you the full lease amount left to pay if you go out of business or want to change credit card services. Word to the Wise…. stay away!

  • Matt

    Smart Choice payments is a scam company. They hire ex cons to obtain your business and allow them access to your bank accounts. They alter paperwork after the fact and stick you with leasing companies that are overcharging for cheap equipment. The whole process is built around a scam. I will never lease another machine as long as I live based on what they have put me through. Never lease a CC terminal other reputiable companies give them to you free.

  • Jennifer Valdez

    Smart Choice Payments’ sales associate Collin Pryor provided false information to persuade me to enter into a merchant services contract that also included a (3rd party) equipment lease. I was reluctant to lease the equipment due to the added monthly expense but he provided a savings estimate that showed my effective rate, including lease expense, would be lower than what I had been previously paying. He also offered a 90-day trial period with no early termination fee so that I could make sure my rates would be lower. This contract was started April 20, 2016. Each month when I got my statement, I emailed him telling him what my rates were working out to be and let him know I would probably need to cancel. Each time he offered to check on what might be getting incorrectly charged or how he could get the rates lowered and I pointed out that with the lease fee, the effective rate would never be what he had quoted. The last time I ever heard back from him was July 11 when he stated he was going to check with customer service to see if they could get the AMEX processing rates lowered and my response to him the next day was that I appreciated him doing that but needed to cancel the account. I emailed him several more times but NEVER heard back from him again. I called customer service and we went back and forth a couple times through voicemail. When I did finally talk to someone, they asked me to send records confirming the 90-day trial as they had no record of it. I forwarded all of my email correspondence between Collin and myself. They did get back to me and agree not to charge an early termination fee but that the lease was out of their hands.

  • fernand

    There’s a reason why smart choice payments has earned my customer loyalty and that’s because I feel like they actually are monitoring and taking care of me as a client. I love that I can go in their website and chat any questions or concerns to customer service and get a response immediately.
    My rep is Colleen Wilson and she is amazing. She loves her company and it shows in her voice she explains things to the fullest.
    I am in a terminal share program that locks in my rates so I never have to monitor my statements. Now
    when other processors call me I have no problem hanging up before they speak. I am happy where I am and I have referred other business to Colleen aka Smart Choice.
    In a nut shell. This company is the SMART CHOICE!

  • Tim Patterson

    Smart Choice Payments Review

    After five difficult years, we met the contract and cancelled.. They then charged us $1000 for failure to return the equipment, equipment that they would no longer service due to security changes. This company is corrupt at worst, and customer unfriendly at best.

    I wish that we had know of your service 5 years ago.

    Are you with Smart Choice Payments? Learn how to resolve this complaint.

Tell Us How They Treated You

Sharing your experience influences our rating and helps other business owners make informed decisions. Please take a moment to tell us if they are serving you well. Your email address will never be published, shared or sold. We only use it to authenticate that you are a real person and, if you select the option for it, to let you know if someone replies to your comment. Required fields are marked *

Comments must contain details about your experience. Please do not use ALL CAPS. Self-promotion, marketing content, or contact information of any kind will not be published. By submitting a comment, you are agreeing to our Comment Policy


Copyright © 2024, Inc. (Digital Fingerprint: 0d38c6720f0d78a701b74d58653af608). Getting paid to re-write this page? Click here to earn a reward.

Any unauthorized copying and reproduction of the content of this page, including all meta data and computer code, is strictly prohibited. While the information in the above article is believed to be accurate as of its publish date, the author and publisher make no representation or warranties with respect to the accuracy, applicability, fitness, or completeness of the contents. The author and publisher shall in no event be held liable to any party for any direct, indirect, punitive, special, incidental or other consequential damages arising directly or indirectly from any use of this material, which is provided “as is,” and without warranties. Any and all use of trade names and/or marks are for identification purposes only and shall not be construed as a claim of affiliation, or otherwise, with, Inc. ("CPO") in any form. The sole purpose of the material presented herein is to alert, educate, and inform readers. It is not intended as legal or financial advice. We may earn revenue if you obtain services from a provider that we recommend. See this page to learn how we support our operations.